Caramel Turtle Pie | Life Love & Sugar

November 8, 2023

1

This submit might include affiliate gross sales hyperlinks. Please learn my disclosure coverage.

This simple Caramel Turtle Pie brings collectively the entire scrumptious flavors of traditional turtle candies and turns them into the most effective pie ever! A buttery Oreo crust is topped with gooey caramel filling, wealthy chocolate ganache, and crunchy toasted pecans! It’s a pie pan stuffed with pure heaven!

Why You’ll Love This Caramel Turtle Pie

In case you like turtle candies, you’ll love this dessert. You simply can’t beat the gooey, melt-in-your-mouth goodness of chocolate and caramel mixed with the satisfying crunch of chopped pecans. Now think about that every one in a pie! Right here’s what retains me coming again to make it repeatedly.

Extremely-decadent. If you’re on the lookout for a gloriously wealthy, candy dessert, you discovered it. The mixture of the candy caramel filling and the wealthy chocolate ganache is excessive (in a great way). I couldn’t cease consuming it!
Texture. I can’t let you know how unbelievable the sleek, ooey gooey caramel filling is subsequent to the smooth buttery crunch of the toasted pecans. Whereas the filling is gooey, it isn’t sticky in a approach that it sticks to your tooth whilst you chew it. It strikes the proper stability. Plus, it stays in place. It’s smooth sufficient to chop into and eat, however not so smooth that’s oozes all over the place.
Straightforward as pie. Pun supposed. Every element of this heart-stopping pie is totally doable for even these of you very new to the kitchen and meeting is tremendous easy as nicely.
Make forward. This dessert will maintain within the fridge for a lot of days (as much as 7!) making it an superior make-ahead choice through the busy vacation season.

Whether or not you serve it on Thanksgiving or a typical Tuesday night time, this dessert is certain to be the discuss of the night. Feeling impressed by turtle sweet? Strive my Turtle Cheesecake as nicely.

What Is Turtle Pie?

A turtle pie is a scrumptious dessert named aptly after scrumptious turtle candies. Turtle candies are comprised of buttery toasted pecans, candy caramel, and wealthy chocolate and so is turtle pie. Whereas I’ve seen many variations of turtle pie, it at all times comprises these three elements: chocolate, caramel, and pecans. Mine incorporates a chocolate crust, a gooey caramel filling, chocolate ganache, and a toasted pecan topping.

Recipe Components

This recipe for turtle pie requires easy and comparatively few components. Right here they’re. You’ll discover the precise measurements listed within the recipe card under.

This easy no-bake caramel turtle pie features a buttery chocolate crust, a gooey caramel filling, rich chocolate ganache, and crunchy pecans.

Oreo cookie pie crust

Oreo crumbs – I put the entire cookie – filling and all – right into a meals processor to create my crumbs.
Unsalted butter – Salted or unsalted would work simply positive.

Caramel filling

Unsalted butter – In order for you a saltier caramel filling, you possibly can use salted butter.
Darkish brown sugar – Whilst you may use gentle brown sugar, the darkish brown sugar provides additional taste to the filling that gentle brown sugar lacks.
Sweetened condensed milk and Heavy whipping cream – The mixture of the 2 kinds the bottom of the caramel sauce. I performed with them a bit and located an equal quantity of every to be greatest. Utilizing all heavy cream resulted in a thinner filling and utilizing all sweetened condensed milk made it too agency and gave it a unique taste.
Corn syrup – The corn syrup helps maintain the caramel filling from changing into grainy, notably because it comes again to room temperature after cooling.

Chocolate pecan topping

Semi-sweet chocolate chips – You can use milk or darkish chocolate chips right here as an alternative.
Heavy whipping cream
Pecans – I extremely suggest utilizing toasted pecans or toasting them your self. It actually brings out the pure buttery taste of the nut.
Caramel sauce – The caramel sauce is non-compulsory however man is it tasty! Quick on time? Retailer-bought caramel sauce will work simply positive.

Straightforward Variations

This pie comprises the identical flavors because the caramel turtle candies you recognize and love and is, for my part, pure perfection. That being stated, you might be greater than welcome to play with the recipe a bit to make it your personal. Listed below are some concepts for you.

Chocolate swap. Be happy to make use of milk or darkish chocolate for the ganache.
Strive a unique nut. Walnuts or slivered almonds could be tasty!
Crust. Not an Oreo crust fan? You can strive a graham cracker crust or use chocolate cookie crumbs as an alternative of Oreos.

Methods to Make Turtle Pie

Making the separate elements for this pie after which placing them collectively is a stroll within the park! Right here’s a fast take a look at how one can do it. Scroll on all the way down to the recipe card under for extra detailed directions.

To make the crust

Prep. Preheat the oven to 350 levels F and Grease a 9-inch pie pan.
Make the crust. Grind the Oreos into positive crumbs in a meals processor and blend with melted butter.
Bake. Press the crust combination into the underside and up the perimeters of the pie pan and bake for 8-10 minutes.

Combining Oreo crumbs and melted butter to make Oreo pie crust.

For the filling

Mix the components. Soften the butter in a big saucepan over medium warmth and add the brown sugar, sweetened condensed milk, heavy cream, and corn syrup. Stir till sugar is dissolved.
Thicken. Deliver the filling to a boil over medium-high warmth and prepare dinner for 2-3 minutes, or till it reaches 220-225°F. Permit it to chill for a few minutes.
Assemble. Pour the caramel into the ready pie crust and refrigerate for 2-3 hours, or till agency.

Filling an Oreo pie crust with caramel filling.

To complete

Make the ganache. Microwave the heavy whipping cream simply till it begins to boil, then pour it over the chocolate chips. Permit it to take a seat for 2-3 minutes, then whisk till easy.
Assemble. Unfold the ganache over the set caramel, prime with chopped pecans, and drizzle with caramel sauce.

Overhead image of caramel turtle pie in a pie dish.

Suggestions for Success

Begin out on the proper foot by learning these easy suggestions and methods earlier than tying in your apron. You’ll be pleased you took the time.

Cautious with warmth. Prepare dinner your caramel over medium-high warmth. Something greater and also you run the chance of burning your filling.
Management the boiling time. Over-cooking the caramel will trigger it to over-thicken and/or burn. Below-cooking it offers you a too-thin filling. You wish to boil it for about 2-3 minutes or till it reaches 220-225°F for optimum consistency. I like to recommend utilizing a sweet thermometer.
Chill. After filling the pie crust with caramel filling, you wish to let it set within the fridge for not less than 2 hours. The time can fluctuate primarily based on how chilly your fridge is. The caramel ought to be agency however give simply ever so barely when pressed into. You’ll additionally wish to enable the totally assembled pie to sit back for not less than a few hours in order that the ganache has an opportunity to agency up.

A slice of caramel turtle pie on a plate with a fork taking a bite out of it.

Correct Storage

Fridge. As soon as set, cowl and retailer within the fridge for as much as 7 days. You should utilize plastic wrap, aluminum foil or an air-tight container.
Freezer. Wrap the utterly set pie in a double layer of plastic wrap or organize slices in an hermetic container. You possibly can retailer it within the freezer for as much as 3 months. Permit it to thaw within the fridge earlier than indulging.

Notes on serving temperature: You possibly can take pleasure in Turtle pie at any temperature. Simply notice that it is going to be just a little firmer when chilly, which might make slicing a bit simpler. It’ll nonetheless maintain its form properly at room temperature, although.

Extra Vacation Pie Recipes To Strive

Set your decadent turtle pie up with some firm on the dessert desk this vacation season. Listed below are a few of my different favorites.

Recipe up to date 11/8/2023.

Print