Copycat Crumbl Cinnamon Roll Cookies

October 24, 2022

1

Gentle, thick sugar cookies are topped with cinnamon filling and a swirl of easy maple buttercream on this epic dessert! In case you’d prefer to expertise heaven on earth, whip up a batch of those Copycat Crumbl Cinnamon Roll Cookies.

Copy cat Crumbl cookies on a wire rack lined with a sheet of parchment paper

These Gourmand Cookies Are Higher Than the Originals!

Having fun with certainly one of these indulgent treats is like sinking your tooth right into a dense, cookie-like cinnamon roll. I like something that comes with cinnamon, and I’m downright obsessive about the melt-in-your-mouth cinnamon combination on prime of those cookies. The velvety maple frosting and the mushy and chewy sugar cookie foundations are equally scrumptious! Collectively, they kind a wonderfully balanced trio that nobody can resist.

The unique Crumbl cinnamon roll cookies are typically a bit candy for me – and that’s coming from a critical candy tooth. Don’t get me flawed – I like them. However I’ve to eat them in halves or fourths due to the extraordinary sweetness degree, so I knew I wished to tone it down for my do-it-yourself model. Don’t get me flawed, these infants are nonetheless candy – simply not so candy that you need to take a break midway by means of your cookie.

Along with firming down the sweetness, I additionally made the buttercream rather less maple-y. The frosting on the unique cookies nearly overpowers the cinnamon roll taste, which I undoubtedly didn’t need on this model. Nevertheless, when you’re a giant maple fan, go forward and pump it again up.

In the end, these cookies are the JAM. They’re not equivalent to Crumbl’s, however the adjustments have been made for a cause. As an added bonus, these new-and-improved cinnamon roll cookies value a fraction of the store-bought ones they’re impressed by!

Two halved cinnamon roll cookies stacked on top of each other

What You’ll Want

The sugar cookie bases, the cinnamon filling and the maple frosting are all made with minimal elements. Take a look at the recipe card towards the underside of this publish for the total quantities.

Sugar Cookies

All-Function Flour: Whereas I take advantage of all-purpose flour, I believe that Crumbl may use cake flour. I personally don’t love the flavour of cake flour, so I caught with all-purpose – however you could possibly completely give cake flour a attempt if desired.
Baking Soda: I discover that this leavening agent produces probably the most tender and chewy leads to cookies.
Salt
Unsalted Butter: Convey this to room temperature earlier than you start.
Sugar: I initially tried including some brown sugar as nicely, however don’t assume that taste was fairly as much like Crumbl’s.
Massive Egg
Vanilla Extract: Use a high-quality model for the very best outcomes.

Cinnamon Filling

Unsalted Butter: Delivered to room temperature.
Gentle Brown Sugar
Floor Cinnamon
All-Function Flour

Maple Buttercream

Unsalted Butter: Room temperature.
Powdered Sugar
Vanilla Extract
Maple Extract: Utilizing maple extract along with maple syrup provides you the very best of each worlds when it comes to taste and colour. However when you’d want to stay with one or the opposite, go proper forward.
Maple Syrup: I like utilizing 100% pure maple syrup.

A batch of copycat Crumbl cinnamon roll cookies on a kitchen countertop with a jar full of cinnamon sticks

Tips on how to Make Copycat Crumbl Cinnamon Roll Cookies

These actually aren’t laborious to make, however there are just a few elements. Let’s get began.

Put together the Dough

Warmth Oven & Prep Pans: Preheat the oven to 350°F and line two baking sheets with parchment paper or silicone baking mats. Set the ready pans apart.

Mix Dry Components: Mix the flour, baking soda and salt in a medium-sized bowl and set the combination apart.

The combined dry ingredients in a bowl with a metal whisk

Fully creamed butter and sugar inside of an electric mixing bowl

Cream Butter & Sugar: Cream the butter and sugar collectively in a big mixer bowl on medium pace till mild in colour and fluffy, about 2-3 minutes.

Add Egg & Vanilla: Add the egg and blend till nicely mixed. As soon as the egg is integrated, add the vanilla extract and blend till nicely mixed.

The combined wet ingredients for the copycat Crumbl cookie dough

The sugar cookie dough being combined in a metal mixing bowl

Add Dry Components: Add the dry elements and blend till the dough is nicely mixed. It is going to be thick. As soon as it’s simply mixed, use a rubber spatula to assist it come collectively to kind a extra cohesive ball. Set the ready cookie dough apart.

Add the Filling & Bake

Make Filling: Add the butter, brown sugar, cinnamon and flour to a medium-sized bowl and stir till nicely mixed. Set the filling apart.

The cinnamon roll cookie filling in a glass mixing bowl

Eight balls of sugar cookie dough arranged neatly on a plate

Kind Dough Balls: Create cookie dough balls of about 6 tablespoons (105g) of cookie dough per ball. You must get 8 balls.

Flatten Into Discs: Place the cookie dough balls onto the ready baking sheets. I baked 4 cookies at a time. Press the balls down a bit with the underside of a cup or one other flat object. They’ll unfold a great bit, so that you don’t must press them down an excessive amount of – however you do want a spot to place the cinnamon combination on prime. After I pressed my dough balls down, they have been about 2 1/2 inches in diameter. They need to crack a bit across the edges.

A short glass being used to gently flatten a ball of cookie dough

Discs of sugar cookie dough on a baking sheet lined with a silicone baking mat

Prime Dough With Filling: Divide the cinnamon combination evenly between the 8 discs of dough, including about 2 tablespoons to every cookie. Place the cinnamon combination on prime of every disc and unfold it out a bit in order that it comes shut (however not all the best way!) to the place the cracks across the edges start. You don’t need the cinnamon combination to overflow off the perimeters of the cookies whereas they bake.

Discs of sugar cookie dough topped with cinnamon filling on a cookie sheet

Four copycat Crumbl cinnamon roll cookies on a lined baking sheet before the frosting has been added

Bake: Bake the cookies for 12-Quarter-hour, or till they appear finished and are nearly to brown on the sides.

Let Cool: Permit the cookies to chill on the pan for 5-10 minutes, then switch them to a cooling rack to allow them to cool fully earlier than you add the frosting. Repeat with the second batch when you couldn’t bake them each without delay.

Make the Buttercream & Assemble

Beat Butter: Add the butter to a big mixer bowl and beat it till it turns into easy and creamy.

Begin Including Powdered Sugar: Add about half of the powdered sugar and blend till easy and nicely mixed.

Add Vanilla & Maple: Add the vanilla extract, maple extract and 1 tablespoon of maple syrup, mixing till the frosting is easy and nicely mixed.

End Including Powdered Sugar: Add the remaining powdered sugar and blend till easy and nicely mixed.

Regulate to Style: Add extra maple syrup till the buttercream reaches your required consistency and taste.

Maple buttercream frosting in a metal mixing bowl

Maple buttercream being piped onto a cinnamon roll cookie in a swirl pattern

Add to Cookies: Pipe the buttercream on prime of the cooled cookies in a swirl design. I take advantage of Ateco tip 806.

Get pleasure from! Serve the cookies instantly or retailer them in an hermetic container till you’re able to get pleasure from them.

Copycat Crumbl cookies on a lined cooling rack on top of a marble surface

Can I Make the Dough Forward of Time?

In case you’re curious about making your sugar cookie dough a day prematurely, wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and retailer it within the fridge. Take away it from the fridge about an hour earlier than you kind your dough balls so it will get an opportunity to melt up.

Suggestions for Success

Aren’t you stunned by how simply these cookies come collectively? Take a look at the next suggestions to ensure they end up excellent.

Measure Your Flour Accurately: An excessive amount of flour may give you cookies that don’t unfold nicely and are dry. I all the time advocate a meals scale to make sure accuracy, however when you don’t have one you should utilize the spoon and degree methodology. Learn extra about measuring your flour precisely right here.
Don’t Overload the Cinnamon Topping: In case you add an excessive amount of of the cinnamon topping or unfold it too far to the sides on the unbaked cookies, it’ll overflow the perimeters of the cookies once they bake. Whereas they nonetheless style nice, they received’t have the identical look.
Let the Cookies Cool Fully: In case you add the buttercream frosting earlier than your cookies have cooled to room temperature, it might get melty and mess up your stunning swirl. Simply be affected person – I promise these cookies might be well worth the wait!

Copycat Crumbl cinnamon roll cookies lined up on a parchment-lined cooling rack

Storage Directions

These cookies will keep recent for as much as 5 days when saved in an hermetic container. In the event that they’re chilled, the sugar cookie bases could begin to dry out, so you should definitely retailer them at room temperature – ideally in a cool, dry place.

Do These Freeze Effectively?

Sure! Place them onto a cookie sheet and freeze them till the frosting is frozen stable, about 1-2 hours. As soon as it’s good and agency, switch the cookies to a freezer-safe container or storage bag and freeze them for as much as 3 months. Thaw the frozen cookies out within the fridge earlier than you get pleasure from them.

See Tips on how to Make Them

Print