Gentle Boiled Egg Salad – The Almond Eater

March 27, 2025

1

This submit might include affiliate hyperlinks. Learn our disclaimer.

This straightforward Gentle Boiled Egg Salad recipe is made with jammy smooth boiled eggs, a mayo and yogurt dressing, and recent herbs to place a creamier twist on a traditional. Stuff it in a sandwich or eat it out of the bowl!

Onerous boiled eggs had been at all times my go-to for old school egg salad as a result of I believed that’s what you had to make use of. Little did I do know that I’d be hooked as quickly as I attempted it with jammy smooth boiled eggs!

I make my recipe for Gentle Boiled Egg Salad on repeat as a result of it’s such a handy, easy, and addictive meal I can eat just about any time of the day. I wish to preserve it actually easy by boiling the eggs within the Immediate Pot (the stovetop works too!) earlier than mashing them with simply mayo, yogurt, and recent herbs. The additional wealthy and creamy outcomes make this egg salad a should for stuffing into sandwiches, spreading on toast, or scooping up with crackers.

In case you’re new to creating egg salad with smooth boiled eggs, it is best to know that it’s barely totally different from the traditional made with laborious boiled eggs. The jammy yolks in smooth boiled eggs give the salad a richer and extra luxurious consistency, whereas laborious boiled eggs have a firmer chunk. Each are nice however an ultra-creamy salad I can scoop up by the cracker-full or unfold on a chunk of toast is heaven in my eyes.

Recipe options

Gentle boiled eggs put an additional wealthy and creamy twist on traditional egg salad, whereas recent herbs take it excessive.
Solely 5 minutes of prep and 20 minutes of cooking make it the proper possibility while you want a quick meal.
Straightforward to customise and revel in your means for breakfast, lunch, a snack, or a scrumptious sandwich filling.

Elements

Eggs – The important thing to this salad is, clearly, smooth boiled eggs! When smooth boiled as an alternative of laborious boiled, the just-set egg whites and golden runny yolks give egg salad an irresistibly creamy texture. I wish to boil my eggs in my Immediate Pot as a result of it’s fast and hands-off, however the stovetop works simply as nicely. Discover the directions within the ideas under.

Mayonnaise – Mayo provides that traditional creaminess. You need to use common mayo or make my do-it-yourself avocado oil mayo for a barely lighter possibility.

Yogurt – Utilizing half mayo and half plain yogurt lightens up the dressing and intensifies the tanginess. Greek yogurt is a superb swap if you would like an additional enhance of protein and a thicker consistency. In case you’re all out of yogurt, merely substitute it with extra mayonnaise.

Contemporary herbs – I used to make this egg salad recipe with recent parsley and recent tarragon till I re-tested it with recent parsley and recent chives, yielding simply as scrumptious and recent bites. Tarragon has a definite anise-like taste, so when you adore it, be happy to toss it in! Dill additionally works right here—combine and match the herbs as a lot as you’d like.

Directions

Step 1: Gentle boil the eggs. In case you haven’t already, smooth boil the eggs within the Immediate Pot or in a pot of boiling water on the range. Keep in mind to set the timer to your most popular doneness and to switch the eggs to an ice bathtub instantly after to cease them from cooking.

soft boiled eggs sliced in half and placed in a bowl

Step 2: Mash and blend. After peeling the boiled eggs, mash them in a big mixing bowl with the mayo, yogurt, recent herbs, salt, and pepper.

2 images: the left image shows all ingredients added to a bowl and the right image shows everything mashed together with a fork

Step 3: Alter the flavour, then serve. Style the salad and add extra salt, pepper, and/or herbs as wanted. Serve and revel in!

Suggestions and FAQs

In case you’re utilizing tremendous recent eggs, add 1 teaspoon of baking soda to the boiling water to assist loosen their shells. Contemporary eggs have a decrease pH, which causes the membrane to stay to the shell. Older eggs are simpler to peel however they received’t style nearly as good.
To make peeling much less irritating, gently faucet the boiled eggs on a tough floor, roll them between your palms to loosen the shell, after which begin peeling from the broader finish the place there’s normally an air pocket.

Tip

How lengthy you boil the eggs for egg salad is dependent upon how you want your yolks. Since we’re making this salad particularly with smooth boiled eggs, 5 minutes and 30 seconds is the candy spot for a wonderfully jammy yolk. For a barely firmer yolk, go for six minutes.

Variations

Add somewhat aptitude to this salad with any of those mix-ins or ingredient swaps:

Add some spice – Stir in a pinch of smoked paprika or chipotle powder for a refined smokiness, or flip up the warmth with a splash of cayenne pepper, chili flakes, Sriracha, or your favourite sizzling sauce.
Make it further tangy – Add a squeeze of recent lemon juice or a spoonful of Dijon or yellow mustard.
Bulk it up with veggies – Finely diced celery, pickles, pink onion, or pink bell pepper will add some bulk, crunch, and colour to the egg salad.
For a protein enhance – Mix the egg salad with shredded hen or drained tuna.
Dairy-free possibility – Swap the common yogurt for a dairy-free yogurt.

Serving options

In case you can resist consuming the egg salad straight from the bowl, I extremely suggest spooning it onto toast or crackers for a easy snack, including a hefty scoop on high of a leafy inexperienced salad for extra protein, or stuffing it into lettuce wraps!

And what egg salad lover can resist smooth boiled egg salad sandwiches? Pile a scoop in between toasted bread and high with lettuce and a tomato slice. You’ll be able to even take your sandwich excessive by including just a few slices of smoked salmon, prosciutto, or crispy bacon.

For a well-rounded meal, be happy to pair your egg salad or egg salad sandwiches with a aspect of radish salad, Mediterranean pasta salad, vegetable couscous, or lemony sauteed asparagus.

How lengthy does it take to smooth boil eggs?

It actually is dependent upon how you want your yolks. For smooth boiled eggs with jammy yolks (the way in which I like ‘em!), boil the eggs for precisely 5 minutes and 30 seconds. In case you desire barely firmer yolks, you may go as much as 6 minutes. Nonetheless you want them, simply keep in mind to start out timing the second they hit the boiling water!

Storage

Make forward: You’ll be able to boil and peel your eggs upfront and refrigerate them in an hermetic container for as much as 2 days earlier than including them to your egg salad.

Fridge: Any leftover egg salad may be packed into an hermetic container and saved within the fridge for two to three days.

Extra traditional creamy salads

In case you made this recipe, make sure you depart a remark and star ranking under. Thanks!