Straightforward Italian hoagies are the final word crowd-pleasing recipe! Deli meats, cheeses, sizzling cherry pepper unfold, and veggies fill lengthy rolls, and create essentially the most scrumptious sub. This recipe is impressed by the hoagie sandwiches I grew up consuming at hoagie retailers in and round Philly!

Italian Hoagie: The Final Submarine Sandwich
Though I now name the Hudson valley residence… I’m initially a PHILLY lady! I spent my complete childhood there and lived there effectively into my 20’s. And whereas my time residing there didn’t flip me right into a Philly sports activities workforce fanatic… it did flip me right into a Philly meals fanatic.
Philly has the very best tomato pie, meatball subs, sausage and peppers, and naturally, Italian hoagies! Between the cities Italian immigrant historical past – and inhabitants – Philadelphia has a vibrant Italian-American meals scene.

Impressed by Well-known Hoagie Retailers
Philly has so many well-known hoagie retailers… however Ricci’s hoagies, Jack’s Place, and Lee’s hoagie home are my household’s favourite spots. However truthfully, you’ll be able to even get a effective hoagie at wawa or Primo hoagies. Once I lived there, I had no must have a “recipe” to make my very own.
However after shifting, I spotted there’s a true artwork to creating a killer Italian sub. With no hoagie retailers anyplace close to my new residence, I set out on a mission to create essentially the most scrumptious submarine sandwich ever! Under are my ideas and tips!
What’s an Italian Hoagie?
- Within the easiest phrases, a hoagie is a sandwich made on an extended roll.
- Historically, employees stuffed them deli meats, cheeses, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and peppers.
- You should utilize one number of deli meat, or you need to use a couple of completely different ones like I do.
- Some folks choose a dry sub, whereas others like mayo, olive oil, cherry pepper unfold, or vinegar.
- Many individuals argue a basic sub is greatest dry or with slightly olive oil. However personally I grew up consuming them with olive oil, vinegar, and cherry pepper unfold. In order that’s what I recommend. You possibly can adapt this to fit your style buds!

Make the BEST Italian Hoagie Sandwiches: Components
- Lengthy Rolls: The most effective hoagie begins with the very best bread! You’ll want to make use of lengthy rolls for this recipe. In the event you’re in Philly, seize rolls from Corrpolese hoagie rolls or Amoroso’s rolls. In the event you’re not, you’ll be able to order lengthy rolls on-line or try your native Italian market/Italian bakery.
- Deli Meats: I take advantage of a mixture of prosciutto, capicola, genoa salami, and soprassata salami. You should utilize ham as a substitute of prosciutto if desired. And reduce down on the meat parts for thinner subs. I prefer to ask my grocer to slice the deli meats and cheeses additional skinny.
- Cheese: Thinly sliced provolone cheese is a should! I don’t recommend subbing this for one more number of cheese.
- Veggies: Romaine lettuce, juicy tomatoes, and onions. I take advantage of crimson onions, however you need to use white or yellow onions.
- Dressing: Pink wine vinegar, dried oregano, olive oil, and sizzling cherry pepper unfold. That is the Sizzling Cherry Pepper Unfold I take advantage of. You possibly can order it on-line or search for it at your native grocery retailer or Italian grocery retailer.
Hog Island: Hoagie Historical past
- Rising up in Philly, I heard plenty of tales on how and the place hoagie sandwiches originated. After some analysis, I’ve discovered that essentially the most extensively accepted model entails a shipbuilding yard, often known as Hog Island.
- Throughout Hog islands prime, it employed over 36,000 folks. Many of those folks have been Italian immigrants.
- For lunch, the Italian employees usually introduced lengthy rolls crammed with deli meats and cheeses. In addition they added greens like lettuce, tomato, onion, and peppers.
- Clearly these scrumptious sandwiches attracted consideration from co-workers, they usually began calling them “the Hog Island sandwich”. Over time, the Hog Island sandwiches earned the nickname of “hoggies”.